myCELLmyTERMS is the answer myCELLmyTERMS is the answer myCELLmyTERMS is the answer myCELLmyTERMS is the answer

My Cellphone My Terms

Public Mobile Plans Review

Posted on June 2nd, 2010Yale Holder
email

Review of Public Mobile Plans

Public mobile launched its network in Toronto on May 26th and is planning to launch in Montreal on June 25th.  Unlike Wind Mobile, Public mobile won’t be launching a national wireless network; it will more likely concentrate in the urban centres like Toronto and Montreal.

There value proposition seems very simple, unlimited plans with cheap phones targeted at the urban, ethnic communities.  Public Mobile paid the least amount for spectrum during the AWS spectrum auction in 2008 a mere $52 million (while the others paid 100s of millions) largely because they chose to go with the unpopular G-Block or unwanted PCS spectrum. Its seems that they were successful in sourcing inexpensive mobile devices for this unpopular spectrum.

What’s to like about their plans?

From the inception, Public Mobile has been talking about their $40 unlimited plans and true to their word, they launched with this plan, so here are the key things I like about Public Mobile:

  • No SAF (system access fees), No 911 fees and no other hidden fees, no credit checks
  • Unlimited plans at $40 which includes  unlimited local calling, unlimited US and CDN text messaging, Voicemail and caller id, call waiting, call forwarding and 3way calling
  • For $45 you can have unlimited CDN long distance
  • $55 for unlimited US and CDN calling
  • their free unlimited CDN long distance for life on signup promotion when they launched, a $5 savings
  • $32 Unlimited local calling ($24 + $8 for Caller ID and Voice mail) which includes call waiting, call forwarding and 3 way calling

What’s not to like?

As I stated in my previous blog on Mobilicity, I’m not a big fan of prepaid, if I’m one day late on my payment I shouldn’t lose my service, while I understand that there must be a balance for having no credit checks and flat unlimited plans – it doesn’t mean I must like it.

Here is my take on where Public Mobile needs improvement:

  • As well as all the new start-ups coverage is going to be limited and given than Public Mobile ONLY bought spectrum in the Winsor – Toronto – Ottowa – Montreal corridor the service is likely to be limited to those areas, so it’s not designed for travelers. In Toronto,  their service runs from the 427 to the beginning of Pickering and goes as far as Steeles
  • CDMA phones! To provide phones at a reasonable rate they used CDMA devices which were tuned to their spectrum which means other CDMA devices won’t work. I guess these devices are ONLY for Public Mobile
  • No Smartphones! Well not as yet. Given that the industry is moving heavily in this direction I believe that in the future Public Mobile will have entry level data devices, in the mean time nothing here
  • No roaming! They indicated that this may be coming; in the meantime don’t travel too far with these devices.

So what’s the bottom line?

Public Mobile doesn’t claim to be anything that it is not. Simple no frills phones targeted at those looking for fixed unlimited plans all within their local areas. And for this Public Mobile does its job. For those who are looking to Public Mobile to be a replacement for Bell, Rogers and Telus, I say, not quite yet. But I do expect that their flanker brands, Koodo, Fido, Solo and Virgin to respond to Public Mobile in the near future.

If you enjoyed this blog use the icons below to share with your friends and colleagues through Facebook, Twitter or by leaving a comment.

  • http://www.mycellphonemyterms.com/General/2010/07/chatr-wireless-plan-review/ Chatr Wireless Plans Review

    [...] [...]

  • http://www.mycellphonemyterms.com/General/2010/12/top-10-cell-phone-news-for-2010/ Top 10 cell phone news for 2010

    [...] with Wind finally getting going in 2010 even though they launched in late 2009, Mobilicity and Public Mobile launched in May and Videotron launched its wireless services in September this [...]

  • Daniel

    FYI Public Mobile does offer roaming now for those looking for this option/service.

  • Stephen M

    I purchased a BUZZ yesterday from Public Mobile. I have to say, it’s the worst piece of garbage I have ever bought. The web browsing capabilities are practically useless. Navigation is poor and the menus are very poorly designed. If you’re thinking you are getting a blackberry alternative, think again. I am very disappointed with this phone.. I tried to return it, but apparently I spent 30 mins on the phone with tech support over why Google Maps doesn’t function. And, if you go over 30mins, no returns/refunds/exchanges… So, I’m stuck with the worst phone ever.. I should have dropped the 300$ on the Blackberry Curve, at least it doesn’t look like a 4yr old designed the GUI. And at least browsing websites isn’t impossible, like the BUZZ.

    Public Mobile shouldn’t buy China-made and designed garbage phones. You’ve been warned! (I wish I was…)

  • Jim

    I bought the Public Mobile Buzz a couple of weeks ago and I have so many dropped calls it’s ridiculous– never had a problem with Fido. At home in Dorval I get 4 or 5 bars and my calls still drop. I was walking in Lachine and I had 3 dropped calls in 5 blocks. Either the phone or the network or both are of low quality. You can only return the phone if you use it for less than 30 minutes, which makes it impossible to test the phone. I spent twice that much time talking to technical support, of course I had to make the calls on my balcony or they would drop. So essentially there is no return on the phone. Don’t buy the Buzz or use Public Mobile, I urge you. Go with another network such as Fido, it’s a little bit more in price but it’s well worth it. Save yourself the frustration.

  • Joed

    What a nightmare, Its been 10 days now since i bought a phone and service from them, I still have not been able to transfer my previous phone number. Customer service is arrogant and kind of lost. I even had a superior who lied to me trying to cover up the mess. To be fair, I asked to transfer a number(my number) which was not active at the time of transfer, but they figured it out 10 days later and now Im left hanging. its technically possible to do but they have no clue.
    You get what you pay for, cheap phones and really bad customer service.

  • Claude Munyankindi

    OH MY GOSH; I am going through the same EXACT thing right now; it is a nightmare. I was told it was to happen the same day, then the next day, and later, someone else told me it takes about 4 days! I’m on the 5th day, and it hasn’t happened yet! And to make it worse, the temporary number that I had been given stopped working. I got a call from a guy who claimed it was HIS number, and an hour later, I couldn’t make or receive any calls.
    At this rate, they won’t be around much longer! Nor will I stay with them!

  • Justaname

    anyone looking to sell their public mobile phone?

  • Tasha

    personally i’m looking to change from public mobile, i mean the service is AMAZING best cell service i’ve ever had, but the problem is not just with the phones but the coverage, they say they cover all of laval and Montreal, yet there are many places i go in both and i have absolutely no service, i’ve asked a rep once why this is and she just apologized because they are a new company. also they showed me the data plan i was amazed, i could download i could do whatever i wanted, thing is… its crap, when i could finally get to a site it takes like 10 minutes for the next page to load. i’m sorry i’m paying 45$ a month for a phone i barely use… thanks public mobile, i’ll see you in the future.

  • Nuno Aguiar

    Do not get a Public Mobile phone there service is bad my wife spent $300.00 on one of there prepaid packages and now she has a phone that can barely be used and is stuck with at least until she runs out of airtime. Go to Public Mobile Sux on Facebook for more info and I would love to hear about your stories too.

  • Rian_sherpa29

    i am using fido now and it sucks coz we have to pay for everything. right now i am paying like $45. i only have 150m call, unlimitated gobal texting, unlimitated incomg call local, call waiting, 3- way call, voice message, and caller id…

  • http://www.patrickbay.ca/ Patrick Bay

    Public mobile phones are, sadly, not even worth the $50 for their cheapest model. They are the absolute bottom of the barrel when it comes to functionality — their Buzz phone, for example, is a wannabe BlackBerry; looks nice on the outside but totally el cheapo in every other respect. For example, on the Buzz phone simple notifications (like you’ve missed a call) have the text running outside of the notification area which is kind of like text on a printed page running beyond the margins. At times it just looks sloppy and half-finished, sometimes it makes the phone unusable because the information is simply not visible. Other “features” on the phone seem completely slapped together or, at times, not even finished (some menu options do literally nothing).

    When I picked up the phone, a replacement for another shoddy Public Mobile phone, the rep. kept going to the back to swap batteries from other phones because, according to him, they tend to have defective batteries. Not more than a week after using the new phone, I can say definitely that he seems to be correct — the battery won’t hold a charge, phone won’t turn on at all even when plugged into an outlet. I wasn’t expecting a miracle but carrying around a $100 brick is not what I was expecting — we’ll see how they deal with it when I try to get a replacement. Next month I’m dropping them altogether.

    Perhaps even worse, pretty much every Public Mobile phone I’ve been on the receiving end of has has awful audio quality, muffled to the point where I can’t understand what’s being said even as the person on the PM phone is shouting into the receiver. I was tempted to blame Public Mobile’s network for this but I’m convinced it has to do with their phones and very poor quality microphones. If you’re okay with producing muffled, human-voice-sounding noises as a form of communication, Public Mobile will probably work okay for you, but if you use human speech to communicate it’ll be tough. Seriously, it’s almost like listening to the adults from Peanuts cartoons — wah wah wah wah.

    Yes, their plans are cheap and pretty much as advertised, so in this respect I have no issue with Public Mobile, but their phones are just awful in pretty much every respect. As I said, I don’t think they’re worth the money you pay for them, especially considering the difficulty in using them to make phone calls (the only thing they can really do).

    Thing is, if they updated their phones or allowed other phones onto their network, Public Mobile might be a good alternative. However, their phones don’t use SIM cards (network access is baked into the hardware) so other phones just aren’t an option, and it seems that Public Mobile is dedicated to giving people the worst options when it comes to hardware so updates don’t seem to be in the cards. To me, this overshadows cheap calling rates — if your phone can’t make phone calls or you can’t make out what’s being said, it doesn’t really matter how much you’re paying for those calls, does it?

    My two cents.

  • Annna

    I love my Buzz it gives me no problems and is way faster than all my friend’s blackberries

  • Wissam

    I would like to express my disappointments about your mobile facilities, espesialy this phone that you called buzz & unfortunatly you consider it as a smart phone from recent generation.
    It’s hard to find where i will start due to long list of unsatisfactory points that i have, i even considered using my line with a normal old phone but unfortunately that even this is impossible with your strategy of having no sim card and this is one of the great handicap that you have since your coverage is miserable the phone battery is not lasting sometimes the day and with your choice of not having the standard USB adaptor so we are unable to charge this devise everywhere & we are not able to switch the line to another charged phone.

    Also considering your USB link that is enable to let you manage anything on the phone except your memory card so am i having a smart device or just a memory card reader?
    This handicap is avoiding us from copying our contacts except by bleutooth and when we do it your device is not capable to get the information properly that gave us a hard work to do by going back to each contact and do the corrections and this is a terror when we are talking about 500 business contacts.
    In addition to all that managing your phone book give you the feeling of that you are using an old mobile created in 1980 wow a retro effect (but not recommended)
    This device is suposed to give me a mail facilities but unfortunatly it just notify me that i got mails in order to manage them somewhere else this if i got them on time because many days i got them with a delay of minimum 4 hours.
    Once you receive an email it is directly displayed on your screen and could be open even if you activate your keyboard lock wich is bad since sometimes the phone is in your pocket and key pad might be pressed by hazard. But the worth is that even if you protect your mail with a password a new email give anyone the possibility to surf inside your saved mail with no single protection.
    In addition to that your useless email system is giving another handicap that you are unable to forward any mail. You only have the choice to reply or read wish is very anoying sometimes and your major mail problem is that your miserable device is not supporting applications that made us unable to open any attachment (sorry guys but buisness mail do have attachments we don’t need mails to chat or sms)
    I have this device since a month and i am manager so using it only in an office but even with this short period the coated black color is scratched & look years old, i never saw something cheaper in my life.
    Also the navigation key is starting not responding or slow.
    Guys even the games on it are very bad (another retro effect) it remind me the attary, and if you play it you can see that it’s not responding many times & drive you crazy
    Lets switch to talk about your signal, wow, you are selling phones at Montreal one of the biggest underground cities, but guess what no public mobile signals there, how should i expect signal underground while i lose signal every time i go into a room with no window?
    So can someone tell me for what i should use this device?? (it’s not heavy enough to use it as door stopper)

    Guess what else!! the 611 the costumer support don’t operate 24hours in 2011 not at least with an automated system.
    And the last joke i had is: yesterday they called me to get my opinion & they called me another time after 2 hours for the same reason, it shows a great organisation, and after hearing my complains they told me that true a lot of persons suffer from the same problems & suggested me to buy a new public mobile device that could solve some of my problems for 140$, so i assume it was a publicity call & not a customer care. but sorry guys for 140 i can get an IPHONE with a deal of three years anywhere in town.
    The handicaps of this buzz are enough to call it back from all the market & give us a new device for FREE maybe we can have a fair deal, i won’t believe that someone will pay another device with you guys.

  • Public Mobile THE worst Phone.

    I just can’t agree enough, Public mobile phones the cheap ones manufactured by ZTE as utterly Trash. They aren’t worth even a penny. I paid 55 for this piece of crap which only worked 2 months and the store warranty is quite tricky. I urge you not to go for public mobile unless you want to use them only for a month or two and pay such a price for all the trouble.

  • CS MEHAN

    Customer Service indeed is bad. The girl over phone was so rude when I was making an inquiry and asked for the address. When I asked for the postal code, she hung up on me. If this is how they treat the prospective customer, I can very well guess how they must be treating their current customer.